Review of Good Profit: How Creating Value for Others Built One of the World’s Most Successful Companies by Charles Koch (Crown Business, 2015).
Adam Smith, a venerable supporter of free enterprise, held businessmen in low regard, alleging that their every meeting “ends in a conspiracy against the public, or in some contrivance to raise prices.” While deference is due to his lasting insights into the sources of the values of men in The Theory of Moral Sentiments and their success in The Wealth of Nations, I observe that many executives tout their “core values,” but not all of these companies are successful. Businessman and philanthropist Charles Koch is successful by any financial measure. His unique approach to the creation of value positions him against Smith’s caricature of scheming backroom businessmen.
Since 1967, Koch has overseen operations at Koch Industries where he developed and implemented “Market-Based Management.” Following a large acquisition by Koch Industries in 2004, he urgently systematized the method and continues to share it. Koch’s first book on the method was grandiosely titled The Science of Success: How Market-Based Management Built the World’s Largest Private Company, but in 2015, he reentered the marketplace of ideas with a more accessible version: Good Profit: How Creating Value for Others Built One of the World’s Most Successful Companies.
Removing the pretense of science from the title better reflects the method’s foundation in the ideas of spontaneous order and the price system articulated by Austrian economist F.A. Hayek. Koch Industries’ business model is based on acquiring complementary companies that either enhance or can be improved by the performance of existing Koch business units. Koch managers seek to integrate these new acquisitions into the company’s operations to realize the expected gains from economies of scale and knowledge sharing. But this integration can blunt the information signals provided by external networks as well as create wasteful internal political battles, especially over budgets and other signs of corporate status unrelated to “good profit.”
To reduce the sclerotic effects of bureaucracy, Koch reintroduces internal market practices. For example, when one Koch business purchases products from another Koch business, the transactions are done at prevailing market prices, not with a “family discount.” Internal support services, such as accounting or credit, compete alongside external service providers to earn the right to serve each Koch business. This is done to ensure good stewardship of economic resources (opportunity cost) and also to avoid wasting human talent and creativity (comparative advantage).
Koch’s book is more business philosophy than process. The book brings to life the observation of Binx Bolling in Walker Percy’s The Moviegoer that “businessmen are our only metaphysicians.” The end to which Koch orders the actions of his company of more than 100,000 people is to earn “good profit” by striving “to be the counter-party of choice to our customers, vendors, communities, and employees.” Striving for this end requires the constant discernment of what your customers value and for how much. To discern and ideally anticipate what your customers need requires a set of personal values to guide decision-making within the organization. In Market-Based Management, the cardinal “guiding principle” is integrity.
Too often integrity is offered up like just another generic corporate value, but trust and reputation are at the heart of commercial life. When a business like online retailer Amazon operates with integrity and a deep commitment to all of its customers, enormous opportunities are created. Netflix, the popular video-streaming service, is a significant business customer of Amazon Web Services (AWS), the cloud-computing platform powering the e-commerce giant and available as a service to startups and Fortune 500 corporations alike. Netflix chooses to use AWS despite competing directly with Amazon Instant Video’s streaming service.
The rise of highly valued and popular two-sided network or marketplace businesses may signal that economist Ronald Coase is due for a revival. The Nobel laureate’s 1937 article answered an ambitious question: Why do firms exist? His simple but powerfully developed response was that transaction costs are not zero and are not ignored by entrepreneurs. Traditionally, entrepreneurs respond to these costs with vertical integration and other supersessions of the price system. At Koch, the formation of employees and selection of partners and customers with integrity is emphasized, partly due to the human duty of moral action but also because of the saved “time and money spent on controls, contracts, litigation, and security.”
The internet has helped entrepreneurs slim down the scope of their firms, instead facilitating peer-to-peer connections (e.g., dating apps) or commerce (e.g., Etsy, Thumbtack). The speed of communication has aided growth, but the most successful marketplace businesses have developed ways of signaling the reputation and integrity of buyers and sellers. New businesses are providing transparency and aggregating reputation so customers and producers can make better decisions (e.g., TripAdvisor, Yelp, Angie’s List). This is both transactional (Where should I stay on my trip?) and character forming (How can our team better serve others?).
Good Profit only briefly notes Charles Koch’s political activities. While the political press focuses on his electoral gamesmanship, Koch spends a significant amount of his philanthropic time and money supporting research and education to enhance the public’s understanding of the integrity of free enterprise. A loss of confidence in free enterprise emerges from the growth of “crony capitalism,” as a Legatum Institute survey reports that 65 percent of Americans believe most big businesses have dodged taxes, polluted or bought favors. In other words, a majority of Americans believe large corporations lack integrity. For his part, Charles Koch has advocated (in the Wall Street Journal and elsewhere) for an end to government subsidies and protectionism favoring some industries, producers and consumers over others. Returning once more to the creation of value, Koch predicts that with the end of corporate welfare and the restoration of integrity in enterprise, “[O]ur economy will rebound. Our liberties will be restored.”
Stephen Schmalhofer writes from New York City.